Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Tarzanrock

(1,191 posts)
39. That's not what Aquinas and Augustine are talking about.
Sat Jun 14, 2025, 10:43 AM
Jun 14

Read Immanuel Kant and The Critique of Pure Reason. The philosophical criticism of Rawls' bullshit is that all sorts of "reasons" can be used to "justify" aggressive military conflicts as philosophically "just wars." Think the 2003 Iraq invasion or Israel's current illegal aggressive warfare attack on Iran. The idea of philosophically justifying pre-emptive aggressive warfare with vacuous philosophical bullshit like Rawls' bullshit is fallacious -- both in law, international law and in ethics. There is no legal nor moral nor ethical/axiological merit to the silly argument that I am justified in hitting some bad motherfucker just because some day some time in the future I believe that bad motherfucker might hit me before I hit him so I am morally "justified" in striking that bad motherfucker first out of some bullshit claim of some sort of "self-defense. Kant suggests that he rejects the very notion of a just war, arguing that the concept is inherently contradictory. He believed that the state of nature is a condition of injustice and that the idea of a "just enemy" is nonsensical.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Such a disappointment he is unweird Jun 13 #1
This old, brain-impaired, Dirty Sweatshirt needs to be thrown into the trash. Tarzanrock Jun 13 #2
I for one, support John Fetterman being deported to Israel. Balatro Jun 13 #3
Coming from PA...... Butterflylady Jun 13 #5
Another from PA harun Jun 13 #16
Pre stroke Fetterman is better than Post stroke Fetterman. SSJVegeta Jun 13 #4
Fetterboy is officially gone ! Nigrum Cattus Jun 13 #6
Beyond sad!! InAbLuEsTaTe Jun 13 #27
I wish this slob would just shut up Wifes husband Jun 13 #7
Fetterman's Not Going Anywhere ... PBC_Democrat Jun 13 #8
So, let me get this straight . . . Richard D Jun 13 #9
Compared to what? Israel's "ethnic cleansing" of the Palestinians in Gaza? Tarzanrock Jun 13 #10
Simple Richard D Jun 13 #11
Israel is under criminal indictment for "War Crimes" Tarzanrock Jun 13 #14
Yeah... Richard D Jun 13 #17
.... MarineCombatEngineer Jun 13 #18
Thank you Richard D Jun 13 #19
And it is so significant that . . . Richard D Jun 13 #20
That tells me that it's not that they don't want to help Iran stop Israel, MarineCombatEngineer Jun 13 #22
I heard... Richard D Jun 13 #33
Pretty sure his guilt is obvious. travelingthrulife Jun 14 #37
Israel is attacking Jordan? sarisataka Jun 13 #34
I support Palestine Avalon Sparks Jun 13 #23
Always with the strawman iemanja Jun 13 #31
That man is sick in the head. ananda Jun 13 #12
Fetterman you should resign you are brain damaged from those strokes. kimbutgar Jun 13 #13
YES and so should NetanYAHOO the war criminal!! InAbLuEsTaTe Jun 13 #28
Just War Criteria: mahina Jun 13 #15
Rawls is full of shit. His so-called 'just war' theory has been legitimately criticized and Tarzanrock Jun 13 #25
Augustine and Aquinus too? mahina Jun 13 #36
That's not what Aquinas and Augustine are talking about. Tarzanrock Jun 14 #39
I hope the PA Democrats are grooming his replacement. malthaussen Jun 13 #21
That is 100 on the 1-10 scale of hate Deminpenn Jun 13 #24
Who's winning? We aren't, and you aren't my friend. twodogsbarking Jun 13 #26
full-blown MAGA stillcool Jun 13 #29
I vote to recall his azz... if only that were possible!! InAbLuEsTaTe Jun 13 #30
No longer a Democrat Picaro Jun 13 #32
Shut Up Fetterman! BidenRocks Jun 13 #35
No doubt David Hogg was targeting Fetterman and was basically FIRED Bengus81 Jun 14 #38
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Fetterman on Israel: 'Kee...»Reply #39