Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

UTUSN

(74,959 posts)
Wed Jul 2, 2025, 02:47 PM Jul 2

And now for a barbarism of the botanical variety: Calling garden botanists, Re, canna plants

Only have had them for a couple of years, always liked them at a distance over decades without knowing what they are like. So first lesson, they are one of those water guzzlers and spreaders, like "elephant ears" and all those leafy tender things, fine. Second lesson, blooms crown the top of very tall, goofy bare stalks, O.K. fine. Third lesson, they need to be "dead-headed" after the blossom poops out, the ball (seed?) needs to be snapped off to allow its energy to channel over to the twin blossom next to it, fine.

So, after the pooping off of a bloom, that stalk is never going to blossom again, so I spent the next year shearing off the upper half of the stalk, leaving the bottom half all leafy and increasingly thick. Plus like with those water guzzlers, these multiply like heck, developing into an ever larger patch in square area and crowdedness. They freeze in Winter unless one of those dedicated gardeners do the thing with the rhizome extravaganza (not me). So frozen, sheared down to the ground leaving the view naked - but no fear, they spring right back in the Spring.

**** The point of this barbarity: After shearing the post-bloom stalks halfway down, leaving ever crowded leafy bottom halves and dead nubs where the blooms were, I have started (now) cutting all of those down-stalk halves at ground level, to thin out the patch. Am willing to hear schooling, but not excessive castigating. Disclaimer, the pic below is from google, but resembles my patch.


9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
And now for a barbarism of the botanical variety: Calling garden botanists, Re, canna plants (Original Post) UTUSN Jul 2 OP
I always cut the stalk all the way down to the ground. Phoenix61 Jul 2 #1
Thanks! - you sound like me talking to myself! UTUSN Jul 2 #2
I grew up with cannas!! Yours are beautiful!! ailsagirl Jul 2 #3
Wow, so you know how purty they are! But water guzzlers and labor intensive. UTUSN Jul 2 #4
All I can say is... ailsagirl Jul 2 #5
My dad couldn't stand cannas because they take over. LudwigPastorius Jul 3 #6
Yip, nice to look at 'em UTUSN Jul 3 #7
Many Years Ago (Cannas) wyn borkins Jul 3 #8
Hah, yeah they entice with their looks, then demand a severe commitment! UTUSN Jul 3 #9

Phoenix61

(18,507 posts)
1. I always cut the stalk all the way down to the ground.
Wed Jul 2, 2025, 02:51 PM
Jul 2

I stopped planting them years ago due to high water needs. I’m on the gulf coast and I swear I could leave the hose running on them and watch them dry out.

UTUSN

(74,959 posts)
4. Wow, so you know how purty they are! But water guzzlers and labor intensive.
Wed Jul 2, 2025, 05:51 PM
Jul 2

The pic is from google but look like mine.

Mine and i have been through a lot - hornets, snails, moths that chewed them to shreds, freeze. Me sometimes not in the mood to deadhead them. Am thinking the thinning out will make things easier.




ailsagirl

(24,270 posts)
5. All I can say is...
Wed Jul 2, 2025, 07:39 PM
Jul 2

they're gorgeous!! My dad planted them in our back yard and I always admired them. As I recall, some were red, others yellow.

Thanks for the memories
👍👍

wyn borkins

(1,372 posts)
8. Many Years Ago (Cannas)
Thu Jul 3, 2025, 12:35 AM
Jul 3

I planted (new to the area) cannas in several neat rows just in front of taller flowering plants. Soon (as in way-to-soon), those durn cannas took-over everything.

I had to dig-out (to a 2-foot level) the entire flowering garden area in an 'attempt' to eradicate them. Even though I no longer live there, those cannas have returned with fury.

Now-a-days, if I wish to see cannas, I refer to the Internet...

UTUSN

(74,959 posts)
9. Hah, yeah they entice with their looks, then demand a severe commitment!
Thu Jul 3, 2025, 08:54 AM
Jul 3

Like you many years ago when I began my very small and very superficial taste of gardening, my first law was to get rid of anything with thorns, with your same principle that if I want to see such plants i will look at pictures.




Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»And now for a barbarism o...