Music Appreciation
Related: About this forum80 Artists Pick Their Favorite Neil Young Song (From Stereogum. Neil Young will be 80 tomorrow, 11/12/25)
And btw, Sterogum is being hurt, very badly, by Google's AI Overview. See this thread on their announcement yesterday: https://www.democraticunderground.com/100220793547
The great Neil Young turns 80 tomorrow.
— Stereogum (@stereogum.com) 2025-11-11T14:39:13.808Z
To celebrate, we asked 80 artists including Jeff Tweedy, Dave Matthews, Brittany Howard, Michael Stipe, Open Mike Eagle, Jewel, Tom Morello, Kurt Vile, Allison Russell, Matt Berninger, Perfume Genius, A-Trak, and many more about their favorite Neil song:
https://stereogum.com/2476602/80-artists-pick-their-favorite-neil-young-song/lists
You get to know Young for yourself, and you find someone with incredible range and incredible consistency. Few artists were as bulletproof-great as Young was for as long he was; fewer still could claim the ongoing cycles of relevance he has shown, with multiple rebirths and resurgences. Beyond setting a standard for his contemporaries, he went on to become the Godfather Of Grunge, and then a hallowed icon for whole swathes of indie music across generations. And through it all, he was always Neil. Whether ragged and brooding at a pump organ, spinning golden melodies around winsome harmonica peals, kicking up cacophony with Crazy Horse, or singing through a vocoder, there were so many iterations of Neil Young and yet, you always knew it was unmistakably him.
Its not just the songs, but the multiplicity of Young that looms large for artists generations removed: yes, a master songwriter, but also a one-of-a-kind guitar hero massively influential on so many different facets of rock music. An activist and maverick, setting not only an example for musical nuts and bolts, but how to carry oneself as an artist. Ive spent the last three months talking to artists about Neil Young, and this was the most common refrain that Young never bent to the will of others, always followed his muse no matter how erratically it darted, and showed how to navigate the music industry and use ones platform with dignity.
Young turns 80 this Wednesday, Nov. 12. To mark the occasion, as we did for Bob Dylans 80th in 2021 and Paul McCartneys 80th in 2022, we asked 80 artists to pick their favorite Neil Young song. Below, youll find one artist for every year Neils been on this Earth, all speaking on the vast inspiration he still provides so many decades on. Happy Birthday, Neil!
-snip-
Goonch
(4,112 posts)vapor2
(3,422 posts)Botany
(75,864 posts)hlthe2b
(112,104 posts)Love ya, Neil
Oh, by the way... A younger generation music producer who leaves impressions of music from decades past has been on a continuing rant about Neil Young's voice--even while other unique Rock music-type vocalists don't seem to bother him. Music tastes are subjective for sure, but in his case it goes quite a ways beyond this... Apparently, he is riling up his YouTube viewers on this as well--not just the few times he's reviewed a Neil Young song, but when he does so with music of his era. I can understand a critical comment, but even while this guy normally seems likable (if incredibly uninformed for a music producer), this has really annoyed me. So, if you'd like to leave him a comment, feel free. (Oh, and if that doesn't irritate you, go to see his comments on Donald Fagen's voice in Steely Dan in his review of "Aja." ) Hmmm.
https://www.youtube.com/@becauseisaac
MichMan
(16,263 posts)2naSalit
(98,869 posts)PufPuf23
(9,665 posts)I started performing the Neil Young song during the pandemic, said Fish. The lyrics have a dark and bleak quality, but they also hint at the possibility of change. Even if Neil intended it to be sarcastic, it resonated with us at that time, and people seemed to enjoy our version, so we decided to record it, she shared. - From BluesRockReview.com.